Flight
Dr. Jay Maron
jaymaron.com


Flight

Wing lift

An wing generates lift at the cost of drag. Lift exceeds drag.

Wing drag force        =  F
Wing lift force        =  F
Wing lift-to-drag coef.=  Qw =  F / F

Wing aspect ratio

The lift-to-drag coefficient Qw is proportional to wing length divided by wing width.

Wing length            =  L
Wing width             =  W
Wing lift-to-drag coef.=  Qw ~  L/W    =  Wing aspect ratio.

Wing lift-to-drag coefficient

Wing width varies along the length of the wing. We define an effective width as

Width = ½ Area / Length

"Area" is the total for both wings, and "Length" is for one wing.

Aspect ratio is Length/Width.

               Qw     Aspect   Wing    Wing   Wing
                      ratio    length  width  area
                               meter   meter  meter2

U-2             23     10.6                            High-altitude spy plane
Albatros        20               1.7                   Largest bird
Gossamer        20     10.4     14.6     1.4    41.3   Gossamer albatross, human-powered aircraft
Hang glider     15
Tern            12
Herring Gull    10
Airbus A380      7.5    7.5     36.3    11.6   845
Concorde         7.1     .7     11.4    15.7   358.2
Boeing 747       7      7.9     23.3    11.3   525
Cessna 150       7      2.6      4.5     1.7    15
Sparrow          4
Human wingsuit   2.5    1        1.0     1.0     2
Flying lemur     ?                                      Most capable gliding mammal.  2 kg max
Flying squirrel  2.0

Wing angle of attack

Changing wing angle changes lift and drag. There is an optimum angle that maximizes the lift-to-drag coefficient.

If the angle is larger than the optimal angle, you gain lift at the expense of drag. If you make the angle of attack too large, lift ceases and the plane stalls.


Air drag

The air drag force is

Air density            =  D  =  1.22 kg/meter2
Velocity               =  V
Cross-sectional area   =  A
Drag coefficient       =  C
Drag force             =  F  =  ½ C D A V2

Parachute at terminal velocity
Human mass             =  M        =  80  kg
Gravity                =  g        =  10  meter/second2
Gravity force          =  F       = 800  Newton
Chute drag coefficient =  C        =   1  Dimensionless
Air density            =  D        =1.22  kg/meter2
Parachute area         =  A        = 100  meter2
Drag force             =  F = ½ C D A V2 = F
Terminal velocity      =  V        = 3.6  meter/second

Maximum speed

Drag force             =  F  =  ½ C D A V2
Drag power             =  P  =  F V  =  ½ C D A V3

     Drag coef    Drag area   Power   Max speed
   dimensionless   meter2     Watt   meter/second


Bike     1            .5        400      11
Car       .4         3       300000      74

Wing drag coefficient

             Cw

F-4 Phantom   .021    (subsonic)
Cessna 310    .027
Airbus A380   .027
Boeing 747    .031
F-4 Phantom   .044    (supersonic)

Gliding

A glider is unpowered. The more efficient the glider, the smaller the glide angle. The minimum glide angle is determined by the wing lift/drag coefficient.

Drag force             =  F
Lift force             =  F  =  Fgrav
Wing lift/drag ratio   =  Qw =  F / F
Horizontal speed       =  V
Vertical descent speed =  V
Glide ratio            =  G  =  V / V
Gravitational force    =  Fgrav
Drag power             =  Pdrag  =  F   V
Power from gravity     =  Pgrav  =  Fgrav V
If the glider descends at constant velocity,
Pdrag  =  Pgrav
The goal of a glider is to maximize the glide ratio
V / V  =  (Pdrag / F)  /  (Pgrav / Fgrav)
         =  Fgrav / F
         =  Qw
The glide ratio is equal to the lift coefficient. Qw = G

Level flight

Air density           =  D
Wing area             =  A
Wing drag coefficient =  Cw
Wing drag             =  F  =  ½ Cw D A V2
Wing lift             =  F
Wing lift/drag ratio  =  Qw  =  F / F
Aircraft speed        =  V
Aircraft mass         =  M
Gravity               =  g   =  9.8 meters/second2
Gravity force         =  Fgrav=  M g
Engine force          =  Feng =  V F
Drag power            =  P  =  F V  =  ½ Cw D A V3
Agility (Power/mass)  =  p   =  P / M  =  V g / Qw
For flight at constant velocity,
Feng = F         Horizontal force balance

F   = Fgrav      Vertical force balance

F   = F Qw      Definition of the wing lift/drag coefficient

Fgrav= Fdrag Qw   →   M g = Qw ½ Cw D A V2

Cruising speed       =  V  =  M½ g½ Qw (½ Cw D A)   ~  M1/6

Agility (Power/mass) =  p  =  M½ g3/2 Qw-3/2 (½ Cw D A)  ~  M1/6

Aircraft energy/mass =  e                              ~  M0

Flight time          =  T  =  e/p                      ~  M-1/6

Range                =  X  =  V T                      ~  M0

For the mass scalings, we assume that wing area scales as M2/3.


Wingtip vortex

A wingtip creates a vortex as it moves. Wingtips are often equipped with a vertical element to damp the vortex. The vertical element increases the effective wing length and improves the lift-to-drag coefficient. coefficient.

Birds fly in a "V" formation to use the updraft from their neighbor's wingtip vortices.


Hovering flight

Hovering propeller

For propellers,

Rotor radius     =  R
Air density      =  D  =  1.22 kg/meter3 at sea level
Rotor tip speed  =  V
Rotor width param=  Cr
Rotor lift force =  F =  D Cr R2 V2
Rotor drag force =  F
Rotor lift/drag  =  Qr =  F / F
Rotor power      =  P  =  F V  =  F V / Qr
Rotor force/power=  Z  =  F/ P
                       =  Qr / V
                       =  R F D½ Cr½ Qr
                       =  R F D½ qr
Rotor quality    =  qr =  Qr Cr½
The physical parameters of a propeller are {Qr,Cr,qr}, with typical values of
Qr = 5.5
Cr =  .045
qr = 1.17
Most propellers have 2 blades and some have 3. If there are 4 or more blades then qr declines.

The parameters are not independent. They're related through the blade aspect ratio.

K  ≈  Aspect ratio
Cr ≈  K
Qr ≈  K
qr ≈  K½

Hovering time
Aircraft mass        =  M
Gravity              =  g
Aircraft force       =  F =  M g
Rotor radius         =  R                  ~  M1/3
Hovering force/power =  Z  =  qr D½ R F  ~  M-1/6
Hovering power/mass  =  p  =  g / Z        ~  M1/6
Aircraft energy/mass =  e                  ~  M0
Hovering time        =  T  =  e / p        ~  M-1/6

Drive propeller

A drive propeller has to move substantially faster than the aircraft to be effective. This distinguishes it from a hovering propeller, which is designed to minimze propeller speed.

Rotor radius      =  R
Air density       =  D  =  1.22 kg/meter3
Aircraft speed    =  U
Rotor speed coef. =  s
Rotor tip speed   =  V  =  s U
Rotor lift force  =  F
Rotor drag force  =  F
Rotor lift/drag   =  Qr =  F / F
Rotor power       =  P  =  F V  =  F V / Q
Rotor force/power =  Z  =  Q / V
Typically, Q ~ 5.5 and s ~ 3.
Power/Mass ratio

A commonly-appearing quantity is the power/mass ratio, which is inversely proportional to the force/power ratio.

Mass              =  M
Gravity           =  g
Rotor quality     =  q
Hover force       =  F  =  M g
Hover power       =  P
Force/Power ratio =  Z  =  F/P
Power/Mass ratio  =  p  =  P/M  =  g/Z

Typical parameters
Air density       =  Dair=  1.22
Seawater density  =  Dwater= 1025
Gravity           =  g   =  9.8     meters/second2
Wing drag coef.   =  Cw  =   .03
Wing Lift/drag    =  Qw  =  7
Rotor lift/drag   =  Qr  =  5.5
Rotor width param =  Cr  =   .045
Rotor quality     =  qr  =  1.17  =  Qr Cr½
Rotor force/power =  Zr
Rotor agility     =  pr  =  g/Zr
Wing agility      =  pw

Propeller-driven level flight
Aircraft mass        =  M
Gravity              =  g
Air density          =  D  =  1.22 kg/meter3
Aircraft speed       =  U
Rotor speed coef.    =  s
Rotor tip speed      =  V  =  s U
Aircraft lift force  =  F  =  M g
Rotor lift force     =  F
Wing lift/drag       =  Qw =  F / F
Rotor drag force     =  F
Rotor lift/drag      =  Qr =  F / F
Rotor power          =  P  =  F V  =  F V / Qr  =  F V / (Qr Qw)
Aircraft force/power =  Z  =  F / P  =  [Qr Qw / s] / U
There is a tradeoff between Qr and s.
Number of rotors

The larger the number of rotors, the less power is required to fly. The efficiency of a rotor is characterized by the force per power.

Number of rotors  =  N
Aircraft mass     =  M
Total rotor mass  =  m
Rotor mass        =  m/N
Rotor constant    =  C
Rotor radius      =  R  =  C m1/3 N-1/3
Gravity           =  g
Force per rotor   =  F  =  Mg/N
Rotor quality     =  q  =  1.17
Air density       =  D  =  1.22
Rotor quality     =  Q  =  q D½  =  1.29
Rotor force/power =  q D½ C (m/N)1/3 (Mg/N)
                  =  q D½ C N1/6 m1/3 M g
For example, in dimensionless units,
Rotors   Rotor   Rotor    Rotor      Rotor
         mass    radius   force   force/power

  1        1       1        1         1
  2         .5      .79      .5       1.12
  3         .33     .69      .33      1.20
  4         .25     .63      .25      1.26
  6         .167    .55      .167     1.35
  8         .125    .50      .125     1.41
 16         .062    .40      .062     1.59

Rubber

Natural rubber
Polybutadiene
Butyl rubber

Rubber has many types, with widely-varying elastic properties. For an aircraft motor, what matters is energy/mass, and butyl rubber does well.

Tensile yield strength   =  t
Tensile modulus          =  Γ
Yield strain             =  Δ  =  t/Γ
Density                  =  ρ
Elastic energy/volume    =  E  =  ½ Γ Δ2
Elastic energy/mass      =  e  =  ½ Γ Δ2 / ρ

                  Tensile Tensile  Yield   Density  Tensile       Common
                  modulus  yield   strain  (g/cm3)  energy/mass   name
                   (GPa)   (GPa)                   (kJoule/kg)

Rubber, butyl         .007    .020    7         .92     186
Rubber, natural       .003    .025    8         .92     104
Rubber, styrene       .006    .0175   4.75      .94      54
Rubber, polyurethane  .006    .025    3.75     1.25      34
Rubber, nitrile       .004    .015    3.5      1.0       19.6
Rubber, silicone      .00066  .0073   7.4      1.25      14.4
Rubber, poly          .015    .005     .92
Rubber, neoprene      .020    .0025    .12     1.23       1.2        Chloroprene

Cotton              15        .5       .1      1.5       50
Gut                           .2

Aramid             135       3         .022    1.43      22.8        Kevlar
Polyamide            5       1         .2      1.14      88          Nylon, Perlon
Polyester           15       1         .067    1.38      24
HMPE               100       2.4       .024     .97      30          Dyneema, Spectra
Vectran PBO        280       5.8       .021    1.52      41          Zylon
Vectran LCAP        65       3.8       .058    1.4       78
Vectran HT          75       3.2       .043    1.41      49
Vectran NT          52       1.1       .021    1.41       8.1
Vectran UM         103       3         .029    1.41      31
Spider silk         10       1.6       .16     1.56      82
Carbon nanorope   1050       3.6       .0034   1.34       4.5
Graphene          1050     160         .152    1.0    12000

Carbon fiber       181       1.6       .0088   1.8       3.9
Magnesium alloy     45        .26      .0058   1.74       .43
Aluminum alloy      70        .41      .0059   2.70       .45
Titanium alloy     116       1.10      .0095   4.51      1.16
Steel alloy        211       1.5       .0071   7.9        .67

For rubber, the numbers for energy/mass are estimations. To get accurate numbers, you need to integrate the full stress-strain curve, and it's nonlinear.

The table is incomplete. Experiments are needed.


Glue

                 Tensile   Density   Set   Cure
                 strength            time  time
                 MPascal   gram/cm3  hour  hour

Epoxy              50       1.18      5      42
Cyanoacrylate      27       1.1        .01   24
Polyvinyl acetate  25       1.19       .3    24      Elmer's glue
Polyurethane       24                 1.5    18
UV glue            20                 -        .01
Silicone rubber     8       1.24      1      42
Rubber cement       5       1.06       .1    12
Duct tape            .01               .01     .01

Altitude

Commercial airplanes fly at high altitude where the air is thin. The thinner the air, the less the drag force and the less the energy required to travel a given distance.

                Altitude   Density
                  (km)     (kg/m3)

Sea level          0       1.22
                   1       1.14
                   2       1.02
Cessna 150         3        .79
Mount Everest      8.8      .46
Boeing 747        11.0      .36
Airbus A380       13.1      .26
Concorde          18.3      .115
F-22 Raptor       19.8      .091
U-2               21.3      .071
SR-71 Blackbird   25.9      .034

History of engines

The most important quality of an engine is power/mass, and the value increases over time. Flight was enabled by the invention of an engine with sufficient power/mass.


Engine           Power/Mass  Year   Type
                    W/kg

Newcomen engine       .5     1712   Steam
Stirling             6       1816   Stirling
Watt engine          2       1776   Steam
Stephenson           5       1829   Steam
Otto                10       1876   Liquid fuel     12% efficient. 3 hp
Wright Flyer       116       1903   Liquid fuel
Gnome Omega        493       1909   Liquid fuel
Mercedes D.I       395       1913   Liquid fuel
Mercedes D.II      426       1914   Liquid fuel
Mercedes D.III     385       1914   Liquid fuel
Rolls Royce Hawk   319       1915   Liquid fuel
Le Rhone 9C        565       1916   Liquid fuel
Mercedes D.III+    491       1918   Liquid fuel
Liberty L12        779       1917   Liquid fuel
Japanese Zero     1429       1939   Liquid fuel        Nakajima Sakai 21 engine

Wright aircraft
Mass                 274  kg
Max takeoff mass     338  kg
Engine power        8900  Watt
Engine mass           77  kg
Engine power/mass    116  Watts/kg
Aircraft power/mass   32  Watts/kg

Aircraft data

Cessna 150
Boeing 747
Airbus 380

SR-71 Blackbird
U-2 spy plane
Concorde
Concorde temperature at Mach 2

         Vcruise  Vmax  Mass  Takeoff  Ceiling  Density  Force  Wing   Len   Wing   Range
           m/s   m/s   ton    ton      km      kg/m3     kN     m2     m     m      km

Cessna 150    42   56     .60     .73  4.3   .79      1.34   15     7.3  10.1    778
Boeing 747   254  274  178.1   377.8  11.0   .36   1128     525    70.6  64.4  14200
Boeing 787-9 251  262  128.9   254.0  13.1   .26    640     360.5  62.8  60.1  14140
Airbus A380  243  262  276.8   575    13.1   .26   1360     845    72.2  79.8  15200
Concorde     599  605   78.7   190.5  18.3   .115   560     358.2  61.7  25.6   7223
F-22 Raptor  544  740   19.7    38.0  19.8   .091   312      78.0  18.9  13.6   2960
U-2          192  224    6.49   18.1  21.3   .071    84.5    92.9  19.2  31.4  10308
SR-71        954  983   30.6    78.0  25.9   .034   302     170    32.7  16.9   5400
Mach 1 = 298 m/s.

Solar powered aircraft
                Cruise  Max  Ceiling  Mass  Cruise  Motor  Solar  Cells  Battery
                 m/s    m/s    kW     tons    kw     kW    cells   m2     tons
                                                            kW

Aquila           35.8          27.4     .40   5.0                          .2
Solar Impulse 2  25.0   38.9   12      2.3           52     66    269.5    .633

The Loon balloon is 15 meters wide, 12 meters, tall, and .076 mm thick. The solar panels generate 100 Watts and the payload is 10 kg. It is too large to be self-propelled and relies and buoyancy modulation and air currents to maneuver.


History of human-powered flight
1961  Piggott accomplishes the first human-powered flight, covering a distance
      of 650 meters.
1977  The "Gossomer Condor 2" flies 2172 meters in a figure-eight and wins
      the Kremer Prize.  It was built by Paul MacCready and piloted by amateur
      cyclist and hang-glider pilot Bryan Allen. 
      It cruised at 5.0 m/s with a power of 260 Watts.
1988  The MIT Daedalus 88 piloted by Kanellos Kanellopoulos flies from Crete
      to Santorini (115.11 km), setting the distance record, which still stands.
Human-powered helicopters can only reach a height of 3 meters and can only hover for 20 seconds.

Agility
               Mass    Power   Agility
               (kg)    (kW)   (Watts/kg)

Human             75    2500     33
BMW i8          1485     170    114
Cessna 150       600      75    125
Airbus A380   276000   49000    178
Formula-1 car    642     619    964
SR-71          30600   33000   1078
F-22 Raptor    19700   33000   1675
If you put a wing on a BMW i8, it would be able to go fast enough to take off.